US court upholds conviction of Mexican drug lord El Chapo

25 January 2022, 18:34

El Chapo Prosecution
El Chapo Prosecution. Picture: PA

His lawyers had argued that the guilty verdict was tainted because some jurors reportedly sought out news accounts.

The conviction of the notorious Mexican drug lord Joaquin “El Chapo” Guzman has been upheld by a US appeals court that praised the trial judge for his handling of a case that drew international attention.

The decision by the 2nd US Circuit Court of Appeals in Manhattan rejected claims that Judge Brian Cogan made rulings allowing a jury to hear faulty evidence at Guzman’s 2019 trial.

Judge Cogan “conducted the three-month trial with diligence and fairness, after issuing a series of meticulously crafted pretrial rulings”, the ruling by the panel concluded.

Guzman, 64, was sentenced to life behind bars for a massive drug conspiracy that spread murder and mayhem for more than two decades.

On appeal, his lawyers had argued that the guilty verdict was tainted because some jurors reportedly sought out news accounts about sex abuse allegations against him that were barred from the trial, and that Judge Cogan erred by not ordering a hearing on the reports.

“The decision seems like it was decided and written before the argument even occurred,” one of Guzman’s lawyers, Jeffrey Lichtman, said in a statement.

“How can there be justice here when the jury was exposed to scurrilous claims against Mr Guzman which were not part of the government’s case?”

The appeals court found that Judge Cogan was to correct in finding “that the jury was not prejudiced by any extraneous information to which they might have been exposed”.

It added: “Any possible prejudice was harmless in view of the overwhelming evidence of Guzman’s guilt.

Before the trial in federal court in Brooklyn, Guzman had attained near-mythical status by escaping from prison twice in Mexico, the second time through a tunnel dug into the shower of his cell.

He was recaptured and sent in 2017 to the United States and put in solitary confinement.

At trial, the defence argued he was the fall guy for other kingpins who were better at paying off top Mexican politicians and law enforcement officials to protect them.

By Press Association

Latest World News

See more Latest World News

Secretary of State Antony Blinken speaks

US accuses Russia of holding world hostage over food amid Ukraine invasion

Nancy Pelosi has issued a warning about the Northern Ireland protocol

Nancy Pelosi threatens to block US/UK trade deal over Northern Ireland Protocol plans

Bush Iraq

George W Bush under fire over ‘brutal’ Iraq invasion slip-up

Ellen Barkin's recorded testimony from 2019 was played in court on Thursday

'Jealous and controlling' Depp threw wine bottle across the room during fight, says ex

Greece Obit Vangelis

‘The world has lost a genius’ – worlds of music and film mourn composer Vangelis

Biden

Joe Biden backs Nato applications from Sweden and Finland

Switzerland Britain Rwanda

Rwandan and UK ministers defend asylum seeker plans after UN criticism

Vangelis

Chariots Of Fire composer Vangelis dies aged 79

Election 2022 Congress

Senate backs huge military and economic aid package for Ukraine

Nato secretary general Jens Stoltenberg gestures as he attends a meeting at Kastellet in Copenhagen, Denmark

Nato addressing Turkey’s concerns over Sweden and Finland – Stoltenberg

The oldest of Moscow’s McDonald’s outlets

McDonald’s era in Russia coming to a close as restaurants sold

Payton Gendron is led into the courtroom for a hearing at Erie County Court in Buffalo, New York

Teenager in court over Buffalo supermarket shooting

Beer cans inspired by the Nato logo by Olaf Brewing Company are displayed in Savonlinna, eastern Finland

Finnish brewery launches Nato beer with ‘taste of security’

Basira Joya, presenter of the news programme, during recording at the Zan TV station (women’s TV) in Kabul, Afghanistan, on May 30 2017

Female Afghan TV presenters ordered to cover their faces by Taliban

Russian army sergeant Vadim Shishimarin during a court hearing in Kyiv, Ukraine

Russian soldier at war crimes trial asks victim’s widow to forgive him

Yuliia Paievska, known as Taira, looks in the mirror and turns off her camera in Mariupol, Ukraine

Captured medic’s bodycam footage shows first-hand horror of Mariupol