Child rape victim receives legal abortion after judge’s refusal sparked outrage

24 June 2022, 03:34

Silhouette and shadow of girl walking down the street
Silhouette and shadow of girl walking down the street. Picture: PA

The judge initially refused the 11-year-old girl’s request for an abortion, suggesting she ‘hold on a little’ longer to save the foetus.

An 11-year-old girl who became pregnant after she was raped has finally received a legal abortion after being blocked for weeks by a judge in Brazil.

The child, who was 10 when she was raped, was in her 29th week (month seven) when the abortion was finally performed on Wednesday night, amid outrage against judge Joana Ribeiro Zimmer for her actions in the case.

Brazil’s judicial watchdog agency said it would investigate Ms Zimmer for asking the child at a filmed hearing on May 9 whether she understood how pregnancies happen and suggesting the girl should “hold on a little more” to save the foetus.

IV solution in a child's patients hand,Close up Children patient's hand receiving iv saline solution in hospital
The judge initially refused the 11-year-old girl’s request for an abortion (Alamy/PA)

The girl repeatedly said she did not want to give birth.

The case had ended up before the judge after doctors refused to perform the procedure because the child was in her 22nd week of pregnancy. Ms Zimmer had subsequently sided with doctors and refused the child’s request.

On Thursday, federal prosecutors in the southern Brazilian state of Santa Catarina said that after a formal request was made on behalf of the girl’s family, Polydoro Ernani de Sao Thiago hospital had taken “measures to interrupt the minor’s pregnancy”.

The case, reported by the website The Intercept Brasil last week, prompted associations of magistrates and human rights groups to ask that Ms Zimmer be removed from her post.

Motion blurred photograph of child patient on stretcher or gurney pushed at speed through hospital corridor by doctors and nurses
The child was in her 29th week of pregnancy when the abortion was finally performed (Alamy/PA)

Some anti-abortion activists have argued that Brazil’s health ministry recommendations urge a 20- to 22-week limit on the procedure.

But Daniela Felix, a lawyer for the family of the child, and other legal experts said Brazilian law makes no mention of a limit in the case of rape victims or when a woman’s life is in danger.

Ms Zimmer said in a statement on Wednesday that she “will not speak about parts of the hearing, which were illegally leaked”. She also said she will remain silent about the case “to assure the due and full protection to the child”.

The probe on Ms Zimmer’s methods will be conducted by the same Santa Catarina court system in southern Brazil and its decision will be referred to her own court in the southern state, and then taken for the national watchdog to make its final decision.

By Press Association

Latest World News

See more Latest World News

Trident test

Russia halts US inspections of its nuclear arsenals

Ahmaud Arbery Hate Crimes

Father and son get life sentences for hate crime over black jogger’s murder

Russia Ukraine War

Russia and Ukraine trade claims over shelling of nuclear power station again

France Heat

France faces worst drought on record as fourth heatwave of the year spreads

Palestinians Israel

Gaza power plant restarts as Israel-Palestinian truce holds

Turkey Russia Ukraine War

Ship carrying grain from Ukraine arrives in Istanbul

Polar Bear Warning Sign

Tourist injured in polar bear attack on Norwegian island

France Whale in Seine

Efforts to feed whale in French river fail again

Solomon Islands Stabbing

US diplomat says Solomon Islands leader ‘missed important opportunity’

King Harald V

Norway’s ageing king discharged from hospital after infection

Israel Palestinians Analysis

Ceasefire between Israel and Gaza militants holds overnight

China Taiwan Military Exercises

China extends military exercises against Taiwan

Woman swimming with nurse sharks in the Bahamas

British boy, eight, savaged by sharks on family holiday 'like a scene out of jaws'

Thailand Pub Fire

Thai pub owner charged in connection with deadly blaze

Virus Outbreak Hong Kong

Hong Kong cuts Covid hotel quarantine for arrivals to three days

Solomon Islands Stabbing

Japanese sailor attacked at Solomon Islands memorial service