Independent probe points to Israeli gunfire in journalist death

16 May 2022, 07:34

A mural of slain of Al Jazeera journalist Shireen Abu Akleh on display in Gaza City
Palestinians Israel Journalist Killed. Picture: PA

Israel and the Palestinians are locked in a war of narratives that already has put Israel on the defensive.

As Israel and the Palestinians wrangle over the investigation into the killing of Al Jazeera journalist Shireen Abu Akleh, several independent groups have launched their own probes.

And one open-source research team said its initial findings lent support to Palestinian witnesses who said she was killed by Israeli gunfire.

The outcome of these investigations could help shape international opinion over who is responsible for Ms Abu Akleh’s death, particularly if an official Israeli military probe drags on.

Israel and the Palestinians are locked in a war of narratives that already has put Israel on the defensive.

Israeli police confront mourners as they carry Ms Abu Akleh's coffin
Israeli police confront mourners as they carry Ms Abu Akleh’s coffin (Maya Levin/AP)

Ms Abu Akleh, a Palestinian-American and a 25-year veteran of the satellite channel, was killed last Wednesday while covering an Israeli military raid in the Jenin refugee camp in the occupied West Bank.

She was a household name across the Arab world, known for documenting the hardship of Palestinian life under Israeli rule, now in its sixth decade.

US secretary of state Antony Blinken on Sunday said he had spoken to Ms Abu Akleh’s family to express condolences and respect for her work “as well as the need to have an immediate and credible investigation” into her death.

Palestinian officials and witnesses, including journalists who were with her, say she was killed by army fire.

The military, after initially saying Palestinian gunmen might have been responsible, later backtracked and now says she may have been hit by errant Israeli fire.

Israel has called for a joint investigation with the Palestinians, saying the bullet must be analysed by ballistics experts to reach firm conclusions.

Palestinian officials have refused, saying they don’t trust Israel.

Human rights groups says Israel has a poor record of investigating wrongdoing by its security forces.

Ibrahim Almasri, an Egyptian freelance photographer, wraps his camera straps around his wrists like handcuffs during a protest as dozens of pro-Palestinian demonstrators gathered near the Israeli Consulate in Istanbul, Turkey, to denounce the death of Ms Abu Akleh
Ibrahim Almasri, an Egyptian freelance photographer, wraps his camera straps around his wrists like handcuffs during a protest as dozens of pro-Palestinian demonstrators gathered near the Israeli Consulate in Istanbul, Turkey, to denounce the death of Ms Abu Akleh (Mehmet Guzel/AP)

After earlier saying they would accept an outside partner, the Palestinians said late on Sunday that they would handle the investigation alone and deliver results very soon.

“We also refused to have an international investigation because we trust our capabilities as a security institution,” Prime Minister Mohammed Shtayyeh announced.

“We will not hand over any of the evidence to anyone because we know that these people are able to falsify the facts.”

He stood with Ms Abu Akleh’s brother, Anton, and Al Jazeera’s local bureau chief, Walid Al-Omari.

With the two sides at loggerheads over the probe, several research and human rights groups have launched their own investigations.

Over the weekend, Bellingcat, a Netherlands-based international consortium of researchers, published an analysis of video and audio evidence gathered on social media.

The material came from both Palestinian and Israeli military sources, and the analysis looked at such factors as time stamps, the locations of the videos, shadows and a forensic audio analysis of gunshots.

The group found that while gunmen and Israeli soldiers were both in the area, the evidence supported witness accounts that Israeli fire killed Ms Abu Akleh.

“Based on what we were able to review, the IDF (Israeli soldiers) were in the closest position and had the clearest line of sight to Abu Akleh,” said Giancarlo Fiorella, the lead researcher of the analysis.

Bellingcat is among a growing number of firms that use “open source” information, such as social media videos, security camera recordings and satellite imagery, to reconstruct events.

Mr Fiorella acknowledged that the analysis cannot be 100% certain without such evidence as the bullet, weapons used by the army and GPS locations of Israeli forces.

But he said the emergence of additional evidence typically bolsters preliminary conclusions and almost never overturns them.

“This is what we do when we don’t have access to those things,” he said.

The Israeli human rights group B’Tselem said it too is conducting its own analysis.

The group last week played a key role in the military’s backtracking from its initial claims that Palestinian gunmen appeared to be responsible for her death.

Protesters hold candles and a photo of Ms Abu Akleh in Haifa, Israel
Protesters hold candles and a photo of Ms Abu Akleh in Haifa, Israel (Ariel Schalit/AP)

The Israeli claim was based on a social media video in which a Palestinian gunman fires into a Jenin alleyway, and then other militants come running to claim they have shot a soldier.

The army said that because no soldiers were hurt that day, the gunmen might have been referring to Ms Abu Akleh, who was wearing a protective helmet and flak jacket.

A B’Tselem researcher went to the area and took a video showing that the Palestinian gunmen were some 300 meters away from where Ms Abu Akleh was shot, separated by a series of walls and alleyways.

Dror Sadot, a spokeswoman for the group, said B’Tselem has begun gathering evidence from witnesses and may attempt to reconstruct the shooting with videos from the scene.

But she said at this point, it has not been able to come to a conclusion about who was behind the shooting.

Ms Sadot said any bullet would need to be matched to the barrel of the gun.

The Palestinians have refused to release the bullet and it is unclear whether the military has confiscated the weapons used that day.

“The bullet on its own can’t say a lot” because it could have been fired by either side, she said.

“What can be done is to match a bullet to the barrel,” she said.

The Israeli military did not respond to interview requests to discuss the status of its probe.

Jonathan Conricus, a former Israeli military spokesman and expert on military affairs, said reconstructing a gunfight in densely populated urban terrain is “very complex” and said forensic evidence, such as the bullet, is crucial to reach firm conclusions.

He accused the Palestinian Authority of refusing to co-operate for propaganda purposes.

“Without the bullet, any investigation will only be able to reach partial and questionable conclusions,” Mr Conricus said.

“One might assume that the strategy of the Palestinian Authority is exactly that: to deny Israel the ability to clear its name, while leveraging global sympathy for the Palestinian cause.”

Meanwhile, Israeli police over the weekend launched an investigation into the conduct of the officers who attacked the mourners at Ms Abu Akleh’s funeral, causing the pallbearers to nearly drop her coffin.

Newspapers on Sunday were filled with criticism of the police and what was portrayed as a public relations debacle.

“The footage from Friday is the very opposite of good judgment and patience,” commentator Oded Shalom wrote in the Yediot Ahronot daily.

“It documented a shocking display of unbridled brutality and violence.”

Nir Hasson, who covers Jerusalem affairs for the Haaretz daily, said the problems run much deeper than Israel’s image.

“This was one of the most extreme visual expressions of the occupation and the humiliation the Palestinian people experience,” he wrote.

By Press Association

Latest World News

See more Latest World News

Oscar Pistorius has met with the father of Reeva Steenkamp

Oscar Pistorius meets victim Reeva Steenkamp's father in a bid for parole

North Korea has blamed its Covid outbreak on 'alien things' and balloons coming from South Korea.

North Korea blames Covid outbreak on 'alien things' and balloons from South

Exclusive
Boris Johnson said Putin does not have to give up power for there to be peace in Ukraine

Putin's made more than 30 nuke threats during Ukraine invasion, Boris tells LBC

Russian President Vladimir Putin has hit back at western leaders for their lack of "machismo" and said it would be ‘disgusting’ to see Boris Johnson topless.

Putin mocks G7 leaders' lack of 'machismo' and says PM would look 'disgusting' topless

Ukraine has retaken Snake Island after Moscow's troops abandoned the strategic outpost in what Russia's Defence Ministry has described as a 'goodwill gesture'.

'Kaboom!' Ukraine celebrates Putin's humiliation as Russia retreats from Snake Island

President Joe Biden listens as Judge Ketanji Brown Jackson speaks

Ketanji Brown Jackson to be sworn in as US Supreme Court justice

An investigator works outside the Bataclan concert hall (Christophe Ena/PA)

Life without parole for surviving extremist who carried out Paris attacks

A shark is seen swimming across a sand bar (Phil Marcelo/AP)

Great white sharks head to Cape Cod as busy tourist season gets under way

Police outside the Bataclan concert hall in Paris (Catherine Wylie/PA)

Men convicted of involvement in 2015 terror attacks in Paris

Salah Abdeslam is believed to be the only surviving member of the group that killed 130 people in the 2015 Paris attacks

Islamic State member found guilty of mass murder for 2015 Paris terror attacks

Vatican Pope Pelosi

Pro-choice Nancy Pelosi receives communion at Vatican despite home city ban

Workers clear debris at the Kremenchuk shopping centre damaged in the Russian rocket attack

Search ongoing for 20 missing after Russian strike on Ukraine shopping centre

People attend a community vigil for the dozens of people found dead in a trailer in San Antonio

‘Difficult process’ identifying Texas lorry trailer death victims – authorities

World Health Organisation chief Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus

US abortion ruling ‘a setback’ that will cost lives, says WHO chief

Dutch farmers protesting against government plans gather for a demonstration at Stroe

Dutch PM condemns farmers’ protests at minister’s home

Cassidy Hutchinson, former aide to Trump White House chief of staff Mark Meadows, is sworn in by committee chairman Bennie Thompson

Trump dismissed January 6 threats and wanted to join crowd, says former aide