Warning new internet laws will hand ministers ‘unprecedented’ powers

27 June 2022, 00:04

Laptop. Picture: PA

The Government is facing calls to ‘slim down’ its Online Safety Bill amid concerns over its impact on people’s freedoms and privacy.

New internet legislation will hand ministers “unprecedented” censorship powers, with significant implications for free speech, new research warns.

The Government is facing calls to “slim down” its Online Safety Bill, which is currently making its way through Parliament, amid concerns over its impact on people’s freedoms and privacy, as well as innovation.

The legislation is set to require platforms legally to protect users from harmful content for the first time, with penalties for breaching the new rules including fines that could run into billions of pounds for larger companies.

Culture Secretary Nadine Dorries has said it will make the UK “the safest place in the world for our children to go online”.

But former ministers have claimed the Bill “panders to the view of the perennially offended”, and could end up “one of the most significant accidental infringements on free speech in modern times”.

A new briefing paper from the Institute of Economic Affairs (IEA) think tank warns that through the establishment of safety duties, the Bill risks digital platforms using automated tools in a “cautious and censorious” manner against content that is “only reasonably considered to be illegal”.

It says the legislation will hand the Secretary of State and Ofcom “unprecedented powers to define and limit speech, with limited parliamentary or judicial oversight”.

Nadine Dorries
Culture Secretary Nadine Dorries (Stefan Rousseau/PA)

Privacy risks will also be raised by a requirement to prevent people encountering illegal or unsuitable material, for example by the general monitoring of user content or use of age verification processes, it claims.

And the think tank alleges the legislation will impose “Byzantine requirements” on thousands of companies, hampering innovation.

Two former Cabinet ministers issued comments voicing their concerns about the Bill, including Lord Frost, who said the best thing the Government could do would be to slim it down.

This would allow it to “proceed rapidly with the genuinely uncontroversial aspects, and consign the rest where it belongs – the waste paper basket,” he said.

He warned the Bill “panders to the view of the perennially offended – those who think the Government should protect them from ever encountering anything they disagree with,” adding that the Tories “should not be putting this view into law”.

David Davis, who was Brexit Secretary from 2016 to 2018, added: “While the Government no doubt has good intentions, in its current form the Bill could end up being one of the most significant accidental infringements on free speech in modern times.”

The Department for Digital, Culture, Media and Sport has been approached for comment.

By Press Association

More Technology News

See more More Technology News

Apps on an iphone screen

WhatsApp unveils new privacy features to boost user security

Snapchat announces new features

Snapchat introduces Family Centre tool to boost child safety

Child online safety measures

Rising number of self-generated child sexual abuse images online reported

NHS 111 service

Warning of NHS 111 delays after cyber attack causes computer system outage

Robots drawing

People are faster at understanding human actions than robotic movements – study

Summer weather July 15th 2022

Parliament closes TikTok account after MPs raise China concerns

The XV (Experimental Vessel) Patrick Blackett

Navy to use experimental warship to test autonomous systems

Amazon Results

Amazon records second quarter loss but revenue tops estimates

A protein shape

DeepMind research predicts structure of almost every known protein

Online Safety Bill amendment

NSPCC: Thousands of child abuse crimes every month Online Safety Bill is delayed

A woman’s finger pressing a key on a laptop keyboard

Meta asks Oversight Board for guidance on Covid-19 misinformation policy

A Boots drone

Drones deliver prescription medicines for pharmacy for first time

Someone playing a video game

Time spent gaming has ‘little to no impact’ on wellbeing, study finds


YouTube brings in £6 billion in advertising revenue in second financial quarter

Phone addiction

Virgin Media O2 increase free data donation in response to rising cost of living

The new Home and Feeds tabs in the Facebook app

Facebook unveils new look Home and Feeds tabs in app refresh