Minister brands eco zealots 'Waitrose-card holders who can afford to pay £1k fines'

10 May 2022, 08:24 | Updated: 10 May 2022, 09:01

Kit Malthouse said protesters such as those from Insulate Britain could afford to pay the fines issued to them
Kit Malthouse said protesters such as those from Insulate Britain could afford to pay the fines issued to them. Picture: LBC/Alamy

By Daisy Stephens

Eco-protesters who block roads are "often Waitrose card-holders" for whom a £1,000 fine is "of no consequence to them", a Home Office minister has said.

Listen to this article

Loading audio...

Speaking on LBC's Nick Ferrari at Breakfast about the Government crackdown on eco protesters due to be outlined in the Queen's Speech, Kit Malthouse said said the current deterrents were not sufficient because the demonstrators could afford to pay the fine.

"The offences that [the police] can prosecute people under don't carry deterrent sentences, so for example obstructing the highway, which was being used when people were blocking motorways, was a level three fine which was up to £1,000 with no threat of prison," he told Nick.

Read more: Crackdown on eco zealots using 'locking on' tactics to be unveiled in Queen's Speech

Read more: 'Entitled' mum slammed for money saving tips which include ditching £40k-a-year nanny

"These individuals, they're often Waitrose card-holders and the money that they have to spend on fines is neither here nor there, so the deterrent effect isn't there, so what we're trying to do is bring more of a deterrent which previously we have done through some of the injunctions that we've obtained... but we need it encoded in the criminal law."

Nick replied: "Just a point of clarification - these protesters are 'Waitrose card holders'?

"What does that mean, Minister?"

Mr Malthouse replied: "I meant very often a £1,000 fine is of no consequence to them."

Eco protesters from Insulate Britain blocked major roads up and down the UK in the second half of 2021, calling on the Government to insulate the UK's social housing stock.

An offshoot of the group, Just Stop Oil, then caused chaos for motorists by blocking oil refineries in April this year.

The Government is expected to announce plans for stricter punishments for such eco protesters, particularly ones who use "lock-on" tactics such as glueing themselves to the highway.

Explaining the plans to Nick, Mr Malthouse said the changes would "bring a more specificity" to the offences and would introduce prison sentences for protesters for the first time.

"One of the things we've experienced is there are a number of these protesters who are very persistent, notwithstanding the fines and the penalties that are handed out they keep coming back again and again," he said.

Read more: The Queen will miss the State Opening of Parliament with Charles to take her place

Watch: Inflation could reach 10% and last until 2024, ex-Bank of England chief economist warns

"So we're going to bring in a thing called a serious disruption prevention order which we can place on them as an individual, which will mean there are specific restrictions on what they can and can't do so as to protect the rest of us."

He said protest was "key to our national identity and our democracy" but added it had to be "balanced against the rights of others to go about their business".

Insulate Britain protesters received fines for blocking roads last year
Insulate Britain protesters received fines for blocking roads last year. Picture: Alamy

Mr Malthouse then defended the police's handing of previous protests, saying: "We got to a situation where those protesters around the M25 were at times being removed within minutes of arriving and as we developed our approach towards those tactics, the police were getting ahead of them faster and faster.

"What we're trying to do today through the Queen's Speech, through this bill, is strengthen the powers that the police have to deal with these protests so that there are proper penalties that will deter them taking place in the first place.

Watch: Andrew Marr: PM will be laughing with relief over Starmer's Beergate resignation vow

Read more: Labour 'can show Keir Starmer did not break lockdown rules' after vow to resign

"We want people to protest, to make noisy protests outside parliament, to talk about these issues, but not in a way that blocks motorways and puts them and the police officers in danger at fuel depots.

"That's what we're trying to achieve through this bill today."

More Nick Ferrari

See more More Nick Ferrari

Exclusive
Boris Johnson said if people visit Rwanda they would see it is "going places"

'You'd change your mind about Rwanda if you visited': Boris defends controversial plan

The Prime Minister was grilled by Nick Ferrari on the last day of the Nato summit

Watch in Full: Nick Ferrari grills Boris Johnson

Exclusive
The PM defended sending billions in support to Ukraine during the cost-of-living crisis

PM defends Ukraine aid in cost of living crisis as he's grilled over '£150k treehouse'

'I won't be shopping in Sainsbury's again but I went back for my apology'

Mum slams supermarket after being told off by worker for breastfeeding in car park

'It's not govt policy to arm Taiwan': Foreign Affairs Committee Chair on Liz Truss' gaffe

'It's not govt policy to arm Taiwan': Foreign Affairs Committee Chair on Liz Truss' gaffe

Ben Wallace said Putin was a 'lunatic'

Putin a 'lunatic with small man syndrome' says minister as PM blasts 'toxic masculinity'

Russian invasion of Ukraine made Nato 'look again' at military capability, says defence chief

Russian invasion of Ukraine made Nato 'look again' at military capability, says defence chief

There's an 'ethical and political vacuum in No10', says former chief of staff

There's an 'ethical and political vacuum in No10', says former chief of staff

Nick Ferrari grilled Priti Patel on her Rwanda migrant plan.

Rwanda migrant plan is not 'appalling' but 'should be a deterrent', Priti Patel tells LBC

Exclusive
Lord Bilimoria, outgoing president of the Confederation of British Industry (CBI) speaks to Nick Ferrari at Breakfast.

'Reduce taxes now': Outgoing CBI chief calls on Rishi to slash 'highest taxes in 70 years'

Grant Shapps has criticised the RMT leader Mick Lynch.

Rail strike called under 'false pretences' by RMT's '1970s union baron' boss, says Shapps

Ofgem chief warns price cap hike 'could be more' than predicted £800

Ofgem chief warns price cap hike 'could be more' than predicted £800

Exclusive
The chairman of Network Rail Sir Peter Hendy has told LBC the industry can be run more effectively with fewer staff.

'Steam age' railway can be run more effectively with fewer staff, rail boss says

Rail strikes will cause "misery for millions"

'Driving unrest and stoking unrealistic expectations': Minister slams RMT ahead of strikes

'What's the point of advisors?!': Nick Ferrari baffled by resignation of Lord Geidt

'What's the point of advisors?!': Nick Ferrari baffled by resignation of Lord Geidt

The minister was speaking to LBC 's Nick Ferrari

Minister calls on Mayor of London to drop congestion charge on rail strike days